Writer: Zahra Kagal / Editor: Maximus Craig
When you type “Sol de Janeiro” into the search bar on MCoBeauty’s website, MCoBeauty’s own perfume mists appear in translucent, color-coded bottles that closely resemble Sol de Janeiro’s best-selling Cheirosa line. MCoBeauty does not pretend otherwise, and on Sept. 30, 2026, in Sol de Janeiro v. MCoBeauty, Judge Edgardo Ramos of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed Sol de Janeiro’s claim that MCoBeauty infringed its packaging. Ramos found that Sol de Janeiro had not adequately alleged its bottle design was nonfunctional and gave the company until Oct. 20 to amend and submit a new complaint. He also rejected Sol de Janeiro’s claim that influencers comparing the two brands’ products amounted to false advertising, treating their comparisons as opinions. The key aspect of this case lies in the claim by Sol de Janeiro, which alleged that the website search itself confuses shoppers into believing the two companies are connected.
In March, a federal judge in Manhattan also found Sol de Janeiro’s Bum Bum Cream jar functional and unprotectable. The ruling is the latest in a series of brands suing and failing to prevail against dupe sellers. Last October, in Deckers Outdoor v. Last Brand, a federal judge held that UGG’s Classic Ultra Mini and Tasman slipper designs were generic, meaning they were so common in the footwear industry the court could not identify a single source and could not protect them as trade dress against Quince’s lookalikes.
Read together, these rulings show the Lanham Act, as courts apply it, offers brands little protection against honest dupes, lookalikes sold under the seller’s own brand name and openly marketed as alternatives. A common thread between these cases is the federal law applied: The Lanham Act.
The Trademark Act of 1946 — or the Lanham Act — protects brand names, logos, and trade dress which is the overall look of a product or its packaging. Registered trademarks and unregistered trade dress have the same test. The brand must show its mark or design is protectable. It also has to show the copy is likely to confuse consumers about who made, sponsored, or approved the product. A brand failing either element loses.
Start with confusion, the heart of every Lanham Act infringement claim. Each federal appeals court has its own list of factors to decide whether confusion is likely. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit uses eight factors decided in AMF Inc. v. Sleekcraft Boats to determine infringement: the strength of the mark, how related the goods are, how similar the marks look, evidence of actual confusion, marketing channels, how carefully buyers shop, the defendant’s intent, and the likelihood the product lines will expand. Honest dupes lose on these factors for one main reason: Their marketing tells buyers exactly whose product they are holding. In Benefit Cosmetics v. e.l.f. Cosmetics a Lanham Act trademark and trade dress case, e.l.f. Cosmetics admitted to taking cues from Benefit Cosmetics’s Roller Lash mascara when developing its own Lash ’N Roll. Benefit nonetheless produced no evidence of actual confusion after e.l.f. sold more than 2.1 million units. Benefit’s trade dress was found to be, “commercially strong” and still ruled for e.l.f., concluding that Lash ’N Roll, “while it is a dupe of Roller Lash,” did not actually dupe any consumers.” Consumer data points the same way. According to a Circana survey results released in August, 51% of beauty buyers have purchased a dupe, and about 70% would intentionally buy one even if they could afford the original. Shoppers who choose a copy on purpose are therefore not usually confused about what they bought.
The Lanham Act has also long allowed sellers to name a rival’s product to describe their own. In Smith v. Chanel, a seller doing business as Ta’Ron advertised its “Second Chance” perfume as a duplicate of Chanel No. 5, seeing if shoppers could tell the difference between the $25 original and the $7 dupe. The Ninth Circuit held the Lanham Act could not stop this advertising, as long as there wasn’t any “misrepresentation or confusion as to source or sponsorship.” Here, a dupe names the original only to describe what it imitates, while the seller’s own name stays on the package.
The protectability element is where most dupe lawsuits typically end. In Wal-Mart Stores v. Samara Brothers (2000) — a Lanham Act trade dress case — the U.S. Supreme Court held that a product’s design is protectable only with proof of “secondary meaning,” meaning consumers have come to see the design itself as a signal of who made it.
The design also can not be generic — Ugg lost in Deckers because Quince showed at least 14 competitors who sold similar ankle-high sheepskin boots. For trade dress not federally registered, the Lanham Act also requires the brand to prove the design is not functional. A design is functional if it is essential to how the product works or affects its quality or cost, and functional features cannot be protected, no matter how recognizable they are. In Apollo Healthcare v. Sol de Janeiro (2026), Sol de Janeiro’s Lanham Act trade dress counterclaim failed because the court held its Bum Bum Cream packaging, a rounded bottom, an oversized lid, a yellow-and-white color scheme, and stylized lettering, was functional, and that combining those elements did not make the overall design nonfunctional. Sol de Janeiro’s claim against MCoBeauty stalled on the same requirement. A specific look many competitors share cannot tell a shopper who made a product, and if a design does not point to one source, copying it cannot mislead anyone about the source. The features that make a design popular enough to copy are often the same features that become too common for any single brand to claim.
Brands would argue that courts sometimes find confusion even when a copier uses its own name. In Lois Sportswear v. Levi Strauss (1986), a Lanham Act trademark case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit barred Lois from using a back-pocket stitching pattern similar to Levi’s trademarked design. Lois relied on “various labels, some permanent and some temporary,” but the court found that shoppers could be confused after purchase, once the labels were “long since discarded.” Ramos, too, concluded that Sol de Janeiro had sufficiently alleged a likelihood of confusion, despite MCoBeauty openly marketing its mists as dupes. Lululemon alleged in its lawsuit against Costco that some customers believed Kirkland products were authentic Lululemon apparel.
However, the cases copiers lose involve a brand’s mark, not just its look, and fashion’s most famous copycat shows the difference. In the 1980s, Harlem designer Dapper Dan printed Louis Vuitton, Fendi, and Gucci logos onto custom clothing without permission. Luxury houses sued him, and after a raid by Fendi — whose legal team included Sonia Sotomayor, now a U.S. Supreme Court justice — he did not reopen his boutique in 1992. Those logos were registered trademarks, protectable on their face, and putting them on clothing told shoppers the brand stood behind it. Dapper Dan satisfied both elements of a Lanham Act claim against himself. Decades later, Gucci sent a fur-sleeved jacket down the runway resembling one Dapper Dan made in 1989. Gucci called it an homage, and even though it faced criticism, no lawsuit followed. Gucci had copied a design, not a mark, and its own monogram told everyone who made the jacket. In that story, Gucci was the honest dupe. Lois falls on the same side of the line as Dapper Dan. Levi’s stitching pattern was a registered trademark the court found had become so associated with Levi’s that it worked like a logo. Lois was copying the brand’s signature, not a common style. Ramos’ confusion finding, meanwhile, came at the earliest stage of the case. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, Ramos at that stage accepted Sol de Janeiro’s allegations as true without deciding whether infringement actually occurred, and even so, the trade dress claim failed on protectability. Lululemon’s allegation was never tested because the companies settled nearly all of their claims before any ruling.
Protecting honest dupes would not leave brands defenseless, because the Lanham Act already polices dishonest ones. Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act covers false advertising, a seller’s false factual claims about its own or a competitor’s products, without requiring the brand to own any design at all. Smith v. Chanel proves the point. After losing in 1968, Chanel returned to court, showed the Ta’Ron perfume was not an exact copy, and won a permanent injunction for false advertising. The Sol de Janeiro v. MCoBeauty (2026) ruling follows the same logic. The claim that survived targets conduct that plausibly misleads shoppers, a search tool that serves MCoBeauty products to people looking for Sol de Janeiro, rather than the copying itself. The right tool for a dishonest dupe is a false advertising claim, not an infringement claim stretched to cover lawful competition.
Brands are right that dupes take sales from brands. But the Lanham Act was built to protect consumers from being deceived about who made a product, not to shield brands from cheaper competition. That is why brands keep losing. The box carries the seller’s name and the marketing announces the product is an alternative, so there is no deception for trademark law to fix. A dupe becomes a real legal problem when it misleads shoppers about what it is, not by being a dupe itself.